Please dont take this the wrong way but what sound can you get from a scratcher that you can't get from another style of caller plus some. I don't claim to be an expert on a scratcher, but it just seems other types of callers are much more versatile.
Randy, you are absolutely right, there IS no sound that you can get from a scratch box that other callers won't make. There are a lot of people, however, who would make the argument that the scratch box will make almost every sound that other callers make and make them as well and in many cases, better, than other callers. They are smaller and easier to carry, are less fragile and make less noise in your vest than most other callers.
Scratch boxes will not gobble, as far as I know, and a kee-kee takes a LOT of practice, but they have a following within the Tenth Legion that borders on being a
cult. I never knew until 10 or 15 years ago, when my Mississippi Scratch Boxes began to earn acceptance in the call making world, just how many people hunt with them, and most of these folks hunt
exclusively with them.
Again, you are absolutely right, but on the other hand, thousands of deceased longbeards can't be wrong, either!