Hen Bone vs. Jake or Gobbler Bone CRAZY!!!!!!

[Trumpetyelper]

I think the vast majority of hen bones are better than gobbler bones.. I think it takes longer to learn to use a gobbler vs. a hen bone.  But i strictly used hen bones for so long.  I just don't know why you would want a larger hole than what is needed.  But.. I will say you sounded awesome on that sound file.  Can you take a picture of the inside diameter of the mouthpiece.  Because a gobbler bone up here looks like a darn snow goose.

Your gobbler bone looks very small.. no joke intended..  shoot a pic of the inside diameter of you get time. 

[KPcalls]

 This sums it it all up.....".Because a gobbler bone up here looks like a darn snow goose."

I rest my case...

[Trumpetyelper]

Looks like a snow goose bone... I am seriously inquisitive about the size of the gobbler bone... from looking at the picture I would have thought that was a hen bone.. I can put a pick of the gobbler bones I am referencing..

[Trumpetyelper]

This is a sound file I just made on my blackberry phone with a wingbone.

[Trumpetyelper]

Im not looking for justification that hen bones are typically better than gobbler bones in reference to mouthpieces I think that is understood by most.  almost all suction yelpers use a 3/32 hole which mimics more of a hen wingbone.  I was trying to see if there was a reason there are so many gobbler bones out there and yes you did answer my question.  People can play them well.  yourself included.  Can you play a hen bone as good or better??

[KPcalls]

This sums it it all up.....".Because a gobbler bone up here looks like a darn snow goose."

I rest my case...

You just said that   "A GOBBLER BONE UP HERE LOOKS LIKE A SNOW GOOSE BONE"  I don't think you know your bones....
 I only came to the defense of gobbler bones being uesd in some calls.  Can a certain gobbler bone be used yes....Can all gobbler bones be used....NO.. are hen bones always better.....NO... it depends on the I.D. of the bones being used.... 

[KPcalls]

And    on your sound file......It takes balls to make one....Most folks won't even try....

[Trumpetyelper]

I just did a better sound file... Here it is.. I have never done that before.. I made it with the program you did. thanks for the insight on the program..
http://www.mediafire.com/?rhy1i9c9yrs05kc

[Trumpetyelper]

your solid on the gobbler bone... I am terrible on the gobbler... terrible.  You selling any gobbler bone wingbone calls that have a good id..  I would be interested in buying one.. Im not a hater.. Im up to try any new call.

[KPcalls]

Good sound file.....

[Trumpetyelper]

interested in selling that call??

[KPcalls]

Here's some pics of different bones I have in the shop.  The first pic from left to right is a small gobbler bone from a southern 2 yr, old, a hen bone from Pa, or N.Y. and a Canada goose bone.





This next pic is in the same order left to right showing the internal deminsions of each....







As you can see this particular hen bone has more of a rounder I.D. than the gobbler bone.  This gobbler bone has a flater I.D.  In comparisn THESE two bones are about equal in internal size.  Trumperyelper, goose bones are typically smaller than hen bones.  I have never used any in the wing bones I make, but have given some to my friend gonehuntn on here who has made some killer cane calls out of them.

Trumpetyelper, I totally agree with you and sooner about the number of wing bone calls out there that are made from the wrong sized bones.  Most of the time its very obvious when they are......

[KPcalls]

interested in selling that call??

 Thanks for asking, but that one is my personal hunting call.

[Daryl]

interested in selling that call??

 Thanks for asking, but that one is my personal hunting call.

You can't go wrong with one of KP's calls. He makes a great caller. 

[GR8CALLS]

Not attempeting to throw a wrench into this debate, but the old timers use to plug the end of a gobbler bone w/ glue and then drill a hole to get the sound they liked.

Bill